Case TS-2DD24F6A11 Nov 2026health_treatment

Pets

“A controlled, randomized study published in the peer-reviewed journal PLOS ONE found that just 14 days of chewing spongy beef bones removes nearly 90% (89.5%) of existing tartar from dogs' teeth." (Post image text: "JUST 14 DAYS OF CHEWING BEEF BONES REMOVES NEARLY 90% OF EXISTING TARTAR FROM DOGS' TEETH," DOI…”

Plain restatementA randomised study in PLOS ONE reported that dogs given spongy beef bones to chew had about 89.5% less visible dental calculus after 14 days, and about 57.7% less after 3 days.

Partially accurate but misleadingConfidence Medium
What this verdict means →

General information only - not veterinary advice.

The study behind this post is real. It is a 2020 PLOS ONE paper in which 12 adult Beagle dogs were randomly assigned to chew one of two types of beef bone daily for about two weeks, and the paper does report a calculus reduction of around 89.5% by days 12 to 14. Two things the post leaves out change the picture. The bones in that study were autoclaved, meaning heat and pressure treated, not raw, while the post uses the result to promote raw bones and says cooked bones are never recommended. The authors also wrote that the bones removed tartar above the gumline only, that this was not enough to remove plaque and calculus under the gumline, and that bone chewing needs to be combined with regular oral prophylaxis, which in veterinary terms means professional dental care. The result comes from 12 laboratory dogs of one breed with heavy existing tartar over 13 days, so it does not establish what happens in dogs generally or over months and years, including tooth fracture risk. Anyone weighing what this means for a particular dog should take that question to a veterinarian, since this is general information and not veterinary advice.

The drift / as claimed vs as evidenced

A [drifted from the evidence:] controlled, randomized study [drifted from the evidence:] published in [drifted from the evidence:] the peer-reviewed journal PLOS ONE [drifted from the evidence:] found that [drifted from the evidence:] just 14 days of chewing spongy beef bones [drifted from the evidence:] removes nearly 90% (89.5%) [drifted from the evidence:] of existing tartar from dogs' teeth." (Post image text: "JUST 14 DAYS [drifted from the evidence:] OF CHEWING BEEF BONES REMOVES NEARLY 90% OF EXISTING TARTAR FROM DOGS' TEETH," DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0228146. Caption adds: "After [drifted from the evidence:] only THREE days, [drifted from the evidence:] tartar was already reduced by 57.7%.")


A [added by the neutral restatement:] randomised study in PLOS ONE [added by the neutral restatement:] reported that [added by the neutral restatement:] dogs given spongy beef bones [added by the neutral restatement:] to chew had about 89.5% [added by the neutral restatement:] less visible dental calculus after 14 days, [added by the neutral restatement:] and about 57.7% less after [added by the neutral restatement:] 3 days.

Red-tinted words in the claim drifted from the evidence. Green-tinted words are what a neutral restatement needs.

The trace / claim to source

Where it appeared
Secondary sourceveterinary professional publication
"The Benefits and Risks of Chew Treats," Today's Veterinary Practice, summarising both studies
Primary sourcepeer-reviewed journal
Pinto CFD, Lehr W, Pignone VN, Chain CP, Trevizan L (2020) "Evaluation of teeth injuries in Beagle dogs caused by autoclaved beef bones used as a chewing item to remove dental calculus." PLoS ONE 15(2): e0228146, published 13 Feb 2020
Primary sourcepeer-reviewed journal copy
Author-deposited full text of the same paper (figures, results wording including the 89.5% figure)
Primary sourceuniversity repository
Underlying thesis for the same experiment, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, describing the protocol (about 4 cm of autoclaved bone daily for 13 days) and group-level reductions
Primary sourcepeer-reviewed journal
Marx FR et al. (2016) "Raw beef bones as chewing items to reduce dental calculus in Beagle dogs," Australian Veterinary Journal 94(1-2):18-23
● Primary source found
What is true
  • The DOI is genuine and the journal is correct. The paper is Pinto et al. 2020 in PLOS ONE, published 13 February 2020.
  • The study was randomised, in dogs, and ran to day 14, and it compared spongy bone against cortical bone.
  • The figure of 89.5% calculus reduction appears in the paper's text, for days 12 to 14.
  • The paper reports that most calculus came off in the first three days and that spongy bone removed calculus more efficiently in the short term, which matches the post's point that softer, porous bone outperformed dense bone.
  • No enamel or root fractures and no obstructions were observed in these 12 dogs over the 13 days of this study.
What is misleading
  • The bones in the cited study were autoclaved, which is a heat and pressure treatment, not raw. The post uses this study to support raw bones and tells readers that vets never recommend cooked bones. The authors state they tested autoclaved bones precisely because of concerns about raw ones. The study therefore does not measure the product the post is about.
  • The post's headline applies the result to "dogs' teeth" in general. The measurement was in 12 adult laboratory Beagles of one breed with heavy pre-existing calculus. A percentage removed from a large deposit in Beagles is not a figure that transfers to all dogs, all ages, all breeds, or all starting levels of tartar.
  • The paper's own conclusion, that the bones must be combined with regular oral prophylaxis and did not remove plaque and calculus below the gumline, is absent from the post. Visible tartar above the gumline is not the part of periodontal disease that causes most harm.
  • "Controlled" implies a comparison against dogs that did not receive bones. The described design compares two bone types; every dog received bone. The control in this study is bone texture, not bone versus no bone.
  • The study whose title is about teeth injuries is used only for its efficacy number. Its finding of no fractures covers 13 days in 12 dogs, which is a short window for an outcome that accumulates over months and years of chewing, and the post presents only the benefit side.
  • The 2016 raw-bone study from the same group reported smaller reductions (about 35.5% at 3 days and 70.6% at 12 days for raw femur bone). The larger numbers in the post come from the autoclaved-bone experiment.
What is uncertain
  • Whether 89.5% is the spongy-bone group's own result or a pooled result across both bone types could not be confirmed from the full results table. At least one citing review attributes about 86% to the spongy-bone group, and the paper's own conclusion speaks of bones generally reducing almost 90%. If 89.5% is the pooled figure, attaching it specifically to spongy bones would be a mis-assignment.
  • The 57.7% three-day figure in the caption is quoted in later literature as coming from this paper, but the source thesis reports day-level reductions of 69.6% for spongy bone and 47.2% for cortical bone, so which timepoint and which arm 57.7% belongs to is unresolved.
  • The funding and conflict-of-interest statement of the PLOS ONE paper was not retrieved, so independence from industry is unestablished.
  • The second study on oral bacteria and the 2025 Frontiers in Veterinary Science review named in the caption were not retrieved and are uninvestigated here. A change in relative abundance of bacteria is not by itself evidence of a change in clinical gum disease, and a review that "explored how chewing may support" wellbeing is not a demonstration of effect.
  • Longer-term safety of repeated bone chewing, including tooth fracture and gastrointestinal obstruction rates, is not answered by a 13-day study in 12 dogs.
Evidence summary

The DOI in the post is real and resolves to a genuine PLOS ONE paper. Its title is "Evaluation of teeth injuries in Beagle dogs caused by autoclaved beef bones used as a chewing item to remove dental calculus." Twelve adult Beagle dogs were randomly allocated in a completely randomised block design to one of two bone types: cortical bone from the femur diaphysis or spongy bone from the femoral epiphysis. Both bone types were autoclaved, that is, heat and pressure treated. Each dog received roughly a 4 cm piece of bone daily for 13 days, with assessments at days 0, 3, 6, 9, 12 and 14. The paper reports that calculus fell sharply in both groups, that most of the removal happened in the first three days, and that spongy bone removed calculus faster in the short term. The paper's text contains the figure of 89.5% dental calculus reduction by days 12 to 14, with teeth coverage falling to about 4.5%. The conclusion states that bones promote a reduction of almost 90% of dental calculus over the teeth and "need to be associated with regular oral prophylaxis," and that the greater efficiency of spongy bone was "not enough to remove plaque and calculus under the gumline." No enamel fractures, root fractures, bone resorption, or oesophageal or intestinal obstructions were observed during the 13 days in these 12 dogs. A separate, earlier study by the same research group (Marx 2016) used raw bovine bones in eight Beagles and reported smaller reductions, summarised in Today's Veterinary Practice as 35.5% after 3 days and 70.6% after 12 days for raw femur bone. Baseline calculus in those dogs covered roughly 42% and 38.6% of the dental arcade areas, so these are percentage reductions from heavy pre-existing deposits in laboratory dogs.

Complete reasoning
The cited paper exists, is in PLOS ONE, is randomised, is in dogs, and does contain the 89.5% figure, so "False" and "Unverified" were both considered and rejected: the number is not fabricated and the source was retrieved. "Accurate" and "Mostly accurate" were rejected because the study used autoclaved bones while the post uses it to promote raw bones and warns against cooked ones, because the result comes from 12 laboratory Beagles with heavy pre-existing deposits rather than dogs in general, and because the authors' own qualifiers, that the effect is above the gumline only and must be paired with regular professional cleaning, are dropped. Those omissions change what a reader would take away, which is the definition of the chosen verdict. Confidence is held at Medium because the full results table was not readable, leaving unresolved whether 89.5% belongs to the spongy-bone arm or to both arms pooled, and because the funding statement was not retrieved.
Use this case

The reply is formatted for pasting into the thread where the claim is circulating.

Ask this case

Answers come only from the case file above; nothing is added.

Is the study behind this claim real?

Yes. It is a 2020 PLOS ONE paper by Pinto and colleagues that studied 12 adult Beagle dogs chewing beef bones daily for 13 days, and the DOI in the post matches this genuine paper.

Were the bones in the study raw, like the post suggests?

No. The bones used in the study were autoclaved, meaning treated with heat and pressure, not raw. The post uses this study to promote raw bones, but that is not what was tested.

Does the 89.5% figure mean dogs' teeth become clean?

No. The paper states the bones removed tartar above the gumline only and were not enough to remove plaque and calculus below the gumline, which is the part of gum disease that causes the most harm. The authors also said bone chewing needs to be combined with regular professional dental care.

Does this study show beef bones are safe for all dogs long term?

The investigation did not establish this. The study only ran 13 days with 12 adult Beagles and found no fractures or obstructions in that short window, but this does not tell us what happens over months or years, or in other breeds and ages.

Was this a controlled study comparing bone chewing versus no bone chewing?

No. Every dog in the study received a bone, either cortical or spongy type. The comparison was between two types of bone, not between dogs who chewed bones and dogs who did not.

Similar cases on record

Partially accurate but misleading: A randomised study in PLOS ONE reported that dogs given spongy beef bones to chew had abou… | TrueSeeker